Skip to main content

Jail De Lima Now?

 The case against Senator De Lima should be dropped without prejudice. 

Looking back at the Marcos era and post EDSA era, many trumped up charges against the opposition have been filed to silence criticism. Make no mistake that this case is not similar to those in the past. Sen. Benigno Aquino was sentenced to die due to alleged possession of illegal weapons. Sen. Panfilo Lacson was implicated in the Dacer-Corbito double murder case. Both charges were found to be fabricated. The two are known critics of past administrations. Globally, authoritarian practices are seen using the judiciary to wreak havoc. Suharto of Indonesia and Najib of Malaysia are known to send their critics to prison. 


So the case of Sen. De Lima is an old fashioned, capricious extension of government muscle.



Atty. Tony Lavina examined the demurrer of Sen. De Lima. He found out that (1) the prosecution failed to establish the conspiracy between Sen. De Lima and certain Jad Dera for the purpose of drug trading. (2) The Anti Money Laundering Council (AMLC) testified that there is no money trail to prove the drug trade. Atty, Lavina, argued that since Sen. De Lima is not found in the physical drug trade or, in esoteric terms, is not found in corpus delicti or body crime, then the evidence against her is not beyond reasonable doubt. Furthermore, physical evidence is not present in the case at bar, e.g. the illegal drugs per se, their quantity or identity. Atty. Lavina questioned the capacity of the court to decide as to the correct penalty because the law provides that it should be based on the identity and quality of the illegal drugs.  

Recently, key witnesses for the prosecution recanted their initial statement that implicated Sen. De Lima in this case. One of them is Rafael Ragos, former deputy director for intelligence at the National Bureau of Investigation. He signed an affidavit disproving all accusations against the senator. Allegedly, he was coerced by the Department of Justice under the supervision of then Sec. Aguirre. The said retraction was put in writing; hence, it is strong evidence that can stand scrutiny in an open court.  

According to literature, those who do not learn from their mistakes are doomed to repeat them. We are the nation that once sent the father of the Philippine revolution, Anders Bonifacio, to trial and execution for political advancement. We repeatedly linked Sen. Aquino to the Maoist movement in the Philippines based on rumors. And we once condemned Sen. Lacson, but later admired him when Cesar Mancao admitted that the past administration coerced him to implicate the senator in the murder case. In the present, we once again repeated the history of putting critical thinkers in prison-box hoping the truth would be incarcerated with them. But as Martin Luther King says: "the arc of the moral universe is long, but it will bend toward justice."


References

  • https://www.hrw.org/news/2022/05/04/philippines-witnesses-retract-testimony-against-duterte-critic
  • https://www.rappler.com/voices/thought-leaders/analysis-crossroads-de-lima-case/
  • https://www.manilastandard.net/news/314225538/another-witness-recants-claim-vs-jailed-de-lima.html

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

STATESMEN V. POLITICIANS

"HUY SI MAYOR NAG DONATE! WOW GALING NIYANG LIDER!" Amid a crisis, the well being of our nation is at risk and these trying times would be an era of darkness for every duly established state. But on the other hand, this would bring us some lesson that is evidently beneficial for our living. The story about philanthropist politicians became viral in social media. The elected officials from national to local government are donating their salaries or money for public use. The said news is well commended by people. Some would say, these people deserve to be elected on their post again, for good leadership. From that let us try to be critical, it is a work of compassion to put your money for mobilization of help in times of crisis but is it necessary to seek public office to become a philanthropist? To set an example, Ramon Ang from San Miguel Corp. and Jack Ma of Alibaba Corp, were able to extend their assistance to the people as a private individual. I'm not questioning t...

HUWAD NA KALAYAAN

Isa bang pagtataksil na isiping mas mahusay kung ang rebolusyon ay nabigo? at baka sakali hindi tayo alipin ng sariling kababayan.  Kagaya ng sinabi ni Gat. Rizal, "Pasasaan pa ang kalayaan kung ang mga alipin ngayon ay sila din namang mang-aalipin bukas." Matapos ang deklarasyon ng kalayaan ng mga Filipino, isang daan taong nakalilipas, patuloy parin ang mga katanungan kung naging ganap ba ang Kalayaan? o naging mga alipin ng sariling kababayan.  Isang araw bago ang pag gunita sa araw ng kalayaan, nag babala ang pambansang pulisya na kanilang bubuwagin ang kilos prostesta ng mga mamayan na umaalma sa panukalang batas na Anti- Terror Bill, alinsunod sa patakaran ng pandemya. Bago ito, ang mga estudyante ng UP Cebu at anim na tsuper ng jeep ay inaresto matapos magpahayag ng saloobin sa pamahalaan. Batid ng lahat ang panganib ng pandemya at lahat ay umaasang ito ay mag wakas. Ngunit ang pag gamit nito bilang instrumento sa pagpapatahimik sa boses ng publiko ay isang op...

Teritoryong Nilimot ng Bayan

Ang mga isla na minsa'y sa atin, ngayon ay nasa kamay na ng Imperyalistang kalaban natin. Apat na taon matapos ang makasaysayang pagkapanalo ng Pilipinas sa Permanent Court of Arbitration sa The Hague Netherlands, Mariin pa rin iginigiit ng Tsina na ang buong West Phillippine Sea ay kanilang teritoryo. Ang pagkapanalo di umano ng Pilipinas ay iligal sapagpakat ang Tsina lamang ang may historikal na batayan sa pag-aangkin dito, naglabas din ang bansa ng Nine dash line, na kung saan ay sinasabing may soberanya ang Tsina sa lahat ng sakop ng linyang ito. Sa kabuuan ay kalahati ng karagatan sa Timog- Silangang Asya ang pasok sa nasabing nine dash line. Sa kabila ng hindi matapos na pang-aabuso ng Tsina sa mga mangingisda at sundalo ng Pilipinas sa West Phillipine Sea, ang gobyerno ng Pilipinas ay mas pinili na tahakin ang ligal na proseso sa pag protekta sa mga teritoryo nito. Batay sa  Sek. 2 Artikulo 2 ng 1987 Konstitusyon  " Itinatakwil ng Pilipinas ang digmaan bilang kasangkap...